Heritage institutions in Canada have been beneficiaries of extractive collection processes and display practices, and though significant improvement is still necessary in care for belongings and repatriation, museums have been making major strides with reparative work (CMA MTA Report, 2022). These difficult histories, realities, and relationalities have been shaping relations between Indigenous or diasporic communities and colonial institutions. However, though often left out of the story, wider visiting publics — both Indigenous and non, professional audiences and general ones — are already implicated in both histories and legacies of harm alongside the work of repair. This presentation explores what it would mean to share stories of custodianship, care, and repatriation with museum visitors. Proposing an UNDRIP-compliant storytelling framework for public education on custodianship and repatriation, this presentation asks how telling stories of repair can open difficult conversations about reconciliation, decolonization, and right relations.